Fuck it il throw my 2 cents in since some people only see what they want to.
Some people dont like playing together its that simple. Some people WILL NOT mesh well in the raid team Metal has right now. I am the most vocal in the raid and trust me i call it all out and i know after the year straight of raiding with the wildstar team that some people will not fit the group regardless or class or dps.
Now for shy being brought in? he joined our raid group when it was 2 split groups. We also had Rhuka join to fill a spot we needed. They arent getting benched before they get a shot because the other group imploded because pugging one was too difficult.
People arent happy they didnt make metals team. Thats fine but why werent you picked? is it because of the class you play, Because your understanding of the class or because you just arent good at FFXIV. Some people are because of reason 1 others of 2 and others of 3 but fuck me some are all the above.
This isnt wildstar you will never overgear current content. Gear doesnt stop a 1 shot in this game. Its that simple.
We set groups for week 1 so that the newer group would have a shot at v1. But people then spoke up saying they dont like raiding with one person or another. Then the raid went shit nothing died and people want in on our group after we already started recruiting.
4 of us arent happy wiping for hours with 0 progression so we made another group instead of sitting 4 people every week. We had permission from Core to split the teams so we did. Everyone who just wanted to raid was put in group 1 and Alia, Lat, Metal and myself made group 2 and started finding people to fill it out with the classes we wanted.
Some people seem to think that they can just coast through because the content is easy. Sure it is but at the current level of some people that easy content is still miles ahead of where they are at.
Pretty much this. We played nice for week 1 and gave ourselves the shit end of the stick yet people keep pushing the fucking button thinking they have some right to a raid spot. This sint WoW or W* this is FFXIV if you arent good enough at FFXIV i dont want you om our raid group. Does that hurt peoples feelings? No idea i think it seems pretty damn straight forward and fair.